Trading in your collection shouldn't be complicated. Whether you're cleaning out your game room or making space for new finds, we offer cash or store credit for trading cards, video games, and consoles. Follow the simple steps below for in-store and mail-in options.
In-Store Trades
- Prepare: Clean your items. Remove cards from binders and sort if possible.
- Bring Them In: No appointment necessary. Early visits recommended for large trades.
- Get an Offer: We assess condition and demand on-site. Large collections may require a drop-off with follow-up in 1 business day.
- Choose Payout: Get paid in cash or take store credit with a bonus. Store credit can be used toward anything in-store.
- ID Requirement: A valid photo ID may be required for larger cash payouts.
- Donation Option: Don’t want to take back low-value items? Let us know and we’ll donate them for you.
Mail-In Trades
- Want to trade from home? Click here for full mail-in instructions.
- Download the Mail-In Form and include it in your package.
- Ship your items to:Fourth Space Games
Attn: Trade-In Department
524 2nd St
Portsmouth, OH 45662 - Receive an offer within 3 business days of delivery.
- All mail-in trade-ins are video recorded for transparency and protection.
- Donation Option: You may indicate on the form if you’d like us to donate any declined items instead of returning them.
What We Accept
- Trading Cards: Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, One Piece, Digimon
- Video Games: From NES to current-gen systems
- Consoles & Controllers: Must be tested and functional
Not Accepted: Headsets, damaged electronics, or Yu-Gi-Oh cards
Card Prep Tips
- Remove cards from binders
- Desleeve anything that’s not high-value
- Group by set, rarity, or game if possible
Example Offers (Cash)
Trading Cards
- MTG Commons: $3 per 1,000
- MTG Rares: $60 per 1,000
- MTG Mythics: $120 per 1,000
- Pokémon Commons: $8 per 1,000
- Pokémon Holos: $16 per 1,000
- One Piece / Digimon: $10 per 1,000
Misc & Games
- Pokémon Jumbos, Pins, Mini Figures: $0.50 each
- Video Games: Priced per title & condition
- Consoles: Offer depends on model, condition & cables
Organized collections get stronger offers. Prices are subject to change based on market trends and store stock levels.
We’re collectors too. We get it. That’s why we keep our trade process fair, respectful, and easy to follow. You’re never obligated to accept an offer, and we’re happy to walk you through how we value your collection.
Questions? Email us anytime.