Trade-Ins

Mail-In Trade-Ins

Can't make it in? Ship us your collection — we'll handle the rest.

← Back to Trade-In overview

High-value submissions (estimated over $300): Please email us before shipping. We want to ensure proper handling and may coordinate partial purchases or returns for large or rare collections.

Step by Step

How It Works

  1. 1

    Clean & Prepare

    Sort your items, remove cards from binders, and desleeve low-value cards. Items with heavy damage may be rejected or valued lower.

  2. 2

    Fill Out the Form

    Download the Mail-In Trade-In Form and include it in your package. It tells us who you are, how to pay you, and what to expect.

    Download Form (PDF)
  3. 3

    Pack Carefully

    Use padding. Make sure nothing shifts in transit. Avoid padded envelopes for anything bulky. Bundle cards in 100s or 500s.

  4. 4

    Ship to Us

    You're responsible for shipping costs. We recommend USPS Priority Mail, UPS Ground, or FedEx with tracking.

    Fourth Space Games
    Attn: Trade-In Department
    524 2nd St
    Portsmouth, OH 45662
  5. 5

    Receive an Offer

    We review packages within 3 business days of arrival. All unboxings are recorded on video for transparency and accuracy.

  6. 6

    Respond Within 10 Days

    Accept or decline the offer. If we don't hear back within 10 days, items become the property of Fourth Space Games.

Getting Paid

Payment & Returns

Payment

We pay via PayPal, CashApp, or Venmo — your choice on the form. Usually sent within 1 business day of acceptance.

Partial Rejection

You'll be paid for accepted items. Return shipping for rejected items is deducted from your payout.

Full Rejection

We'll invoice you for return shipping before sending items back.

Donation Option

Don't want to pay return shipping on declined items? Check the donate box on your form and we'll find them a good home.

Questions before you ship? Reach out first — we're happy to walk you through it.

Email Us